The 2010-S Millard Fillmore Presidential Dollar is worth anywhere from $2 in circulated condition to $10 or more in top proof grades, with some certified examples fetching even higher prices among dedicated collectors. If you recently found one of these coins or inherited a collection that includes it, you’re in the right place to find out exactly what it’s worth.
What Is the 2010-S Millard Fillmore Dollar Coin?
The 2010-S Millard Fillmore Presidential Dollar is part of the United States Mint’s Presidential Dollar Program, which ran from 2007 to 2016. This series honored every former U.S. president in the order they served, and Millard Fillmore — the 13th president — got his turn in 2010 alongside fellow presidents Martin Van Buren, William Henry Harrison, and John Tyler.
The “S” mint mark means this coin was struck at the San Francisco Mint, and it was produced exclusively as a proof coin. That’s an important distinction. Proof coins are specially made with polished dies and planchets, giving them a mirror-like finish that business-strike coins simply don’t have. They were sold directly to collectors in special sets, so you won’t typically find one of these in everyday pocket change.
If you’re trying to figure out what you’ve got, a coin identifier and value app can help you confirm the mint mark, date, and grade right from your smartphone — no coin shop visit required.
How Much Is the 2010-S Fillmore Dollar Worth?
The value of a 2010-S Millard Fillmore Presidential Dollar depends heavily on its grade and condition. Since these were only made as proofs, most examples still look quite nice. However, even proof coins can be damaged by improper storage, handling with bare fingers, or years of neglect in a box somewhere.
Here’s a general breakdown of current market values:
| Grade | Description | Estimated Value |
|---|---|---|
| PR-65 | Gem Proof, minor contact marks | $4 – $6 |
| PR-67 | Superb Proof, nearly flawless | $6 – $9 |
| PR-69 | Near-perfect surfaces | $9 – $15 |
| PR-70 | Perfect Proof (PCGS/NGC certified) | $20 – $50+ |
A perfect PR-70 example graded by a top service like PCGS or NGC can push into the $30–$50 range. These are rare but out there. For comparison, you can also look at 2010 dollar coin value data across different series to understand how similar issues from the same year are performing in the market.
Mintage Numbers and Why They Matter
The 2010-S Millard Fillmore Presidential Dollar had a mintage of approximately 1.47 million coins. That might sound like a lot, but compared to the billions of business-strike coins produced for circulation each year, it’s actually quite modest. Low mintage numbers tend to support long-term collector interest and can help maintain or grow a coin’s value over time.
Because these coins were sold in proof sets and not released into general circulation, a large portion of surviving examples were cared for by collectors from the start. That means many are still in excellent condition, which is why you rarely see heavily worn examples at coin shows or auctions.
Still, not every 2010-S Fillmore dollar is in top shape. If yours was removed from its original government packaging, set loose in a drawer, or stored without proper protection, it may have developed hairline scratches or toning that could reduce its grade — and its value.
How to Check the Value of Your 2010-S Fillmore Dollar Right Now
If you want the most accurate valuation without spending money on a formal appraisal, your best bet is to use a dedicated coin pricing tool. CoinHix is one of the most reliable options available today. It pulls real market data from recent sales so you can see what collectors are actually paying — not just theoretical estimates.
You can also check current pricing data for 2010 dollar coins in MS grades to get a sense of how the broader market for 2010-dated dollar coins is trending. While that page focuses on the Native American series, it gives useful context for understanding collector demand during that same year.
CoinHix also lets you track your collection over time, which is handy if you’re sitting on more than just one coin and want to keep an eye on values without checking auction sites manually every week.
Is the 2010-S Fillmore Dollar Worth Keeping or Selling?
Honestly? It depends on what you’re after. If you found this coin in an old proof set or inherited a collection, it’s probably worth holding onto — especially if it’s still in its original mint packaging. The coin won’t make you rich overnight, but it’s a legitimate collectible with a stable market and genuine historical appeal.
Presidential dollars as a series have a dedicated following, and coins from the early years of the program — including 2010 issues — continue to attract interest. If you ever decide to sell, platforms like eBay, coin shows, or dedicated collector forums are good starting points. And if you’re building a collection, tools like CoinHix make it easy to stay on top of pricing trends without having to dig through auction records yourself.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is the 2010-S Fillmore Dollar rare?
A: It’s not considered rare in the traditional sense, but with a mintage of about 1.47 million and limited collector circulation, it’s far less common than typical pocket-change coins. High-grade certified examples, especially PR-70, are genuinely hard to find.
Q: Can I find a 2010-S Fillmore dollar in my change?
A: No. The “S” mint mark means it was made only as a proof coin at the San Francisco Mint and sold in special collector sets. It was never released for general circulation, so you won’t encounter one in everyday transactions.
Q: Does the original government packaging affect the coin’s value?
A: Yes, it can. Coins kept in their original U.S. Mint proof set packaging are better protected from scratches and environmental damage. An unpackaged coin is more likely to have hairlines or toning that can reduce its grade and therefore its market value.